Astronomers are keeping a close watch on asteroid 2024 YR4, a space rock that initially caused concern for Earth but now poses a slight, intriguing risk to our Moon in 2032. While the chance of an Earth impact is now incredibly low, a newly updated analysis suggests a 4.3% probability that this asteroid could collide with the lunar surface, potentially creating a spectacular, visible event and raising new questions about safety in space.
Contents
From Earth Threat to Lunar Target
When asteroid 2024 YR4 was first spotted in late 2024, initial tracking suggested a small but noteworthy chance it could hit Earth on December 22, 2032. At one point, the estimated risk briefly climbed, making it seem like the most concerning object tracked in recent history. This naturally caught the attention of planetary defense experts and the public alike.
However, as scientists gathered more observations, the asteroid’s path became much clearer. Like refining a blurry photograph, each new data point helped pinpoint the asteroid’s trajectory more precisely. This improved understanding quickly reduced the estimated chance of an Earth impact to near zero – thankfully, our planet appears safe from this particular visitor.
But the refined orbit revealed something new: the asteroid’s path brought it increasingly close to the Moon. Planetary scientist Dr. Andrew Rivkin from Johns Hopkins University explained that as the position uncertainty moved away from Earth, it shifted towards the Moon.
What an Impact Might Look Like
According to the latest analysis from NASA’s Center for Near-Earth Object Studies (CNEOS) at JPL, based partly on observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), there is now a 4.3% chance that asteroid 2024 YR4 will collide with the Moon on December 22, 2032. If it does, it would pass within just 0.00007 Astronomical Units (AU) of the Moon – an incredibly close shave, considering 1 AU is the Earth-Sun distance.
While a direct hit on Earth would have been catastrophic, the prospect of a lunar impact is viewed with a mix of scientific interest and awe. Richard Moissl, head of the European Space Agency’s Planetary Defence Office, noted that an impact could be visible from Earth and would definitely leave a new, observable crater on the Moon.
A new study led by Paul Wiegert at the University of Western Ontario modeled what such a collision might entail. Their findings suggest the impact could release energy equivalent to about 6.5 megatons of TNT. To put that in perspective, the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima was about 0.015 megatons, making this impact potentially hundreds of times more powerful. The resulting crater could be roughly 1 kilometer (about 0.6 miles) in diameter.
The team highlights that, statistically, this could be the largest impact on the Moon in approximately 5,000 years, offering a rare scientific opportunity.
Diagram illustrating the positional uncertainty of asteroid 2024 YR4's potential trajectory towards the Moon in 2032
Beyond the Spectacle: Risks in Space
The most intriguing, and potentially concerning, finding from the new study relates to the material ejected from the Moon’s surface by the impact. The model estimates that up to 108 kilograms of lunar debris could be launched at speeds exceeding the Moon’s escape velocity, meaning it would fly off into space.
This ejected debris could become more than just scientific curiosity. While it might create spectacular, albeit unpredictable, meteor showers visible from Earth (with a small chance of lunar meteorites reaching the surface), it also poses risks to assets in space.
The study warns that particles ejected from the impact could significantly increase the hazard to satellites orbiting Earth. The flux of these small particles (0.1 – 10 mm size range) could be 10 to 1,000 times higher than the normal background sporadic meteor flux, potentially for years or even a decade after the impact. This level of increased risk could be dangerous for spacecraft and even astronauts during spacewalks.
Furthermore, the ejected material could pose risks to operations closer to the Moon, such as NASA’s planned Lunar Gateway station or future surface missions, as some material falls back towards the lunar surface. This highlights a need to extend planetary defense thinking beyond just Earth impact and consider cis-lunar space – the region between Earth and the Moon.
What Comes Next?
While the potential for a spectacular Moon impact is fascinating, it’s important to remember the chance is still below 5%. We won’t know for sure if it will hit, or exactly where, for some time.
Asteroid 2024 YR4 is currently too far from Earth for telescopes to observe it clearly. However, its orbit will bring it back into our vicinity in 2028. At that point, astronomers will have another opportunity to track it precisely. More observations will further refine its path, allowing scientists to calculate the impact probability with even greater accuracy and potentially determine the exact location if an impact is predicted.
NASA has stated they expect to make further observations in 2028. Meanwhile, research like the new study is already prompting discussions about potential responses if the risk is confirmed.
Ultimately, asteroid 2024 YR4 presents a unique scenario: a low-probability event with the potential for a rare cosmic display and newly identified challenges for our growing presence in space. Scientists will be watching in 2028, eager for more data on this intriguing celestial visitor.
